Comparing Natural and Synthetic Structured Data: A Study of the Passive Verb Alternation in French and Italian
This study compares the impact of natural and synthetic data on training and evaluating large language models (LLMs), using the case of passive verb alternation in French and Italian. We use Blackbird Language Matrices (BLMs), structured datasets designed to probe linguistic knowledge of underlying patterns across sentence sets. We compare structured templates instantiated with natural sentences extracted from Universal Dependencies to structured templates of synthetic sentences. Experiments show that while models achieve ceiling performance when trained and tested on synthetic datasets, they — Giuseppe Samo, Paola Merlo
View PDF HTML (experimental)
Abstract:This study compares the impact of natural and synthetic data on training and evaluating large language models (LLMs), using the case of passive verb alternation in French and Italian. We use Blackbird Language Matrices (BLMs), structured datasets designed to probe linguistic knowledge of underlying patterns across sentence sets. We compare structured templates instantiated with natural sentences extracted from Universal Dependencies to structured templates of synthetic sentences. Experiments show that while models achieve ceiling performance when trained and tested on synthetic datasets, they do not reliably generalize to natural sentences. In contrast, models trained on natural data exhibit robust performance across both natural and synthetic test suites, demonstrating their superior ability to capture abstract linguistic patterns. These results corroborate the value of natural data and of structured set ups in linguistic evaluation for probing LLMs' syntactic and semantic knowledge.
Comments: 13 pages, 8 figures, paper accepted at the Workshop on Structured Linguistic Data and Evaluation (SLiDE)
Subjects:
Computation and Language (cs.CL)
Cite as: arXiv:2603.25227 [cs.CL]
(or arXiv:2603.25227v1 [cs.CL] for this version)
https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2603.25227
arXiv-issued DOI via DataCite (pending registration)
Submission history
From: Giuseppe Samo [view email] [v1] Thu, 26 Mar 2026 09:27:58 UTC (201 KB)
Sign in to highlight and annotate this article
Conversation starters
Daily AI Digest
Get the top 5 AI stories delivered to your inbox every morning.
More about
researchpaperarxiv
How AIRA2 breaks AI research bottlenecks
While we've seen remarkable progress in AI for coding and mathematics, creating agents that can navigate the messy, open-ended nature of real research (where things break for no obvious reason) has proven far more challenging.
Exclusive | Caltech Researchers Claim Radical Compression of High-Fidelity AI Models - WSJ
<a href="https://news.google.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?oc=5" target="_blank">Exclusive | Caltech Researchers Claim Radical Compression of High-Fidelity AI Models</a> <font color="#6f6f6f">WSJ</font>
Exclusive | Caltech Researchers Claim Radical Compression of High-Fidelity AI Models - WSJ
<a href="https://news.google.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?oc=5" target="_blank">Exclusive | Caltech Researchers Claim Radical Compression of High-Fidelity AI Models</a> <font color="#6f6f6f">WSJ</font>
Knowledge Map
Connected Articles — Knowledge Graph
This article is connected to other articles through shared AI topics and tags.
More in Research Papers
AI Inspires New Research Topics In Materials Science - miragenews.com
<a href="https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMihwFBVV95cUxQRlVFdkRBaHRvYkJJdFRlMTZmajEzeFRPU0hGWWdfbi02V1FnTUdVQ2pmY2VZLUV2NlB4V3BFdEVlSVZkUlhRSTZaNWFKMmcyWXJYbnNqbUhMTmp0NnFtMEppOXlPZkJSNHJfck5VSEVYcmUtX1k2QkJlR1BvUEdTTkp3UmlYRkk?oc=5" target="_blank">AI Inspires New Research Topics In Materials Science</a> <font color="#6f6f6f">miragenews.com</font>
From brain scans to alloys: Teaching AI to make sense of complex research data - Penn State University
<a href="https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiwAFBVV95cUxPZDFHdkptQ2VUM2hmWjhqQkxoRnBiTWoxMXRRR21MUG5TamdUMlFRWmhvYVNHaFVNREVKU3VmSnVOdDVZYnNLb2ppYXRVRTZmVFVMV1pLTlVhUm9ybTNZbGtvZTdIMnIyMHNpOEk5aU9TSmxxS2Y4V2MwazYwY3JlX1Axbk1nd3pfcWhFdUJaaDJWRXJaMFIyTTROcmFHeXI3ZzFudXJ2M1h6UHI1LW1Ca1dta2RkM3BiYndocGk3Yjg?oc=5" target="_blank">From brain scans to alloys: Teaching AI to make sense of complex research data</a> <font color="#6f6f6f">Penn State University</font>
Locating Risk: Task Designers and the Challenge of Risk Disclosure in RAI Content Work
arXiv:2505.24246v4 Announce Type: replace Abstract: As AI systems are increasingly tested and deployed in open-ended and high-stakes domains, crowdworkers are often tasked with responsible AI (RAI) content work. These tasks include labeling violent content, moderating disturbing text, or simulating harmful behavior for red teaming exercises to shape AI system behaviors. While prior research efforts have highlighted the risks to worker well-being associated with RAI content work, far less attention has been paid to how these risks are communicated to workers by task designers or individuals who design and post RAI tasks. Existing transparency frameworks and guidelines, such as model cards, datasheets, and crowdworksheets, focus on documenting model information and dataset collection process
Togedule: Scheduling Meetings with Large Language Models and Adaptive Representations of Group Availability
arXiv:2505.01000v5 Announce Type: replace Abstract: Scheduling is a perennial-and often challenging-problem for many groups. Existing tools are mostly static, showing an identical set of choices to everyone, regardless of the current status of attendees' inputs and preferences. In this paper, we propose Togedule, an adaptive scheduling tool that uses large language models to dynamically adjust the pool of choices and their presentation format. With the initial prototype, we conducted a formative study (N=10) and identified the potential benefits and risks of such an adaptive scheduling tool. Then, after enhancing the system, we conducted two controlled experiments, one each for attendees and organizers (total N=66). For each experiment, we compared scheduling with verbal messages, shared c
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion
No comments yet — be the first to share your thoughts!